Was Mahler killed by his own symphony?

by Stephen Johnson,

The Telegraph – 2 March 2020


In 1910, right at the end of his life, Gustav Mahler finally made his breakthrough as a composer. Until then, music-lovers across the western world saw him as a great conductor who also composed.

Yet such was the brilliance of the Eighth Symphony, right from that thunderous, organ-enhanced invocation of the Holy Spirit at the opening, that any doubts were swept away. The audience in Munich, including representatives of several European royal houses and an impressive number of A-list musical and literary names, including Thomas Mann, Stefan Zweig and Arthur Schniztler, roared its approval.

The symphony premiered at a difficult time for Mahler. Not only was the Austrian-born composer in ill health but, just months before, he had made the horrifying discovery that his wife and muse, Alma, was ready to leave him for the architect Walter Gropius. Yet, when he filled Munich’s vast new music hall for two successive evenings (due to a brilliant, intensive and very modern-looking PR campaign by Mahler’s impresario, Emil Gutmann), this tiny, physically frail figure appeared charged with demonic energy from the moment he raised the baton.

However, opinion on the quality of the Eighth has proved divisive over the past 110 years. Verdicts of the great and famous have varied from ‘ecstatic’ and ‘heaven-storming’ to ‘empty’, ‘laboured’ and ’shameless Kitsch.’

His ‘Eighth’ offers an inclusive, idealistic world vision, but it may have taken a fatal toll on the composer 

Opinion is also divided over the meaning of the Eighth. Shortly after its premiere, Mahler died from pneumonia at the shockingly young age of 50. Was it the colossal exertion of this do-or-die performance that ushered in his final decline, and his death only months later? Does this reflect back in some way on the Eighth Symphony’s content?

Certainly not in the context of his final two works – the Ninth Symphony and the ‘song-symphony’ Das Lied von der Erde (‘The Song of the Earth’), both unperformed at his death.  With these it was clear – or so it seemed –  that Mahler had seen his own end coming, and bid the world he loved an agonised protracted farewell in these two astonishing scores.

He was also looking boldly into the future, whereas the Eighth, as the philosopher Theodor Adorno later stated, was a monumental mask.  With its Catholic-flavoured mysticism, it belonged to the past – the Austrian Imperial past that the First World War was soon to sweep away.

As a Jew who was at the vanguard of the cultural revolution of Vienna in the early 1900s, this seems extraordinary. But Mahler’s relationship between past and present, between different countries is complex. He called the new symphony, ‘My gift to the entire nation’, by which he clearly means Germany. Over the years ‘Germany’, for Mahler, evolved into something much more ideal, an inclusive, humanist tradition embodied in Goethe and Beethoven, whose choral Ninth Symphony had famously offered a ‘kiss for the whole world’. Mahler believed in the notional unity of German-speaking peoples that was felt to transcend national, and even imperial borders, and disregarded race or religion. And just look at the symphony’s manifest content: Goethe, the iconic German ‘universal man’, whose Faust provides the setting for the final words of Part Two, and in Part One a medieval hymn composed by the Archbishop of Mainz, Rabanus Maurus, then treasured as the ‘Teacher of Germany’.  Furthermore, In his student days Mahler had belonged to a pan-German nationalist movement, the Pernerstorfer Circle.

And what about his famous comment, made the year the Eighth was finished, that ‘the symphony should be like the world’, drawing everything into its embrace?

In the wider German world there was, of course, a sinister side to this world-embracing ambition. As the historian Golo Mann pointed out, 1910 was a time of strenuous German colonial expansion, a time when the word ‘world’ (Welt) was prefixed to many German nouns: the world-city Berlin, German world-standing, German world-trade, world politics, world history and, most ominously of all, world power. Could it be that Mahler was in some way cheering on the Kaiser?

It seems unlikely. Mahler’s interest in politics (if that’s what it was) dwindled rapidly after his student days. He wanted to escape the world, not to march in with sleeves rolled up intent on changing it. As a Jew, and as a self-confessed ‘outsider everywhere’, Mahler would have had a very different kind of ‘Germany’ in mind from that espoused by the more strident political breed of nationalists. It was belief in humanity, or rather in human potential, liberated by sublime art and thought, and represented in the sacred figures of Goethe, Kant and Beethoven, and later in Wagner and Nietzsche.

If those two last names ring alarm bells given Mahler’s Judaism, it should be remembered that Nietzsche turned against nationalism and anti-Semitism as he turned against Wagner. There is a story that someone presented him with a pamphlet entitled, ‘German culture without the Jew’. Nietzsche handed it back with the words, ‘What German culture without the Jew?’ For educated, assimilated German and Austrian Jews in the late-19th and early 20th centuries these figures opened up an ideal, even transcendent world of culture and art, with music very much at the centre.  In that case Mahler’s stupendous gift to the nation held out an image to German-speaking people everywhere – and through them to the rest of the world – not of what they were, but of what they might become.

For this reason it’s important not to endorse the suggestion that the Goethe text in the symphony’s Second Part is an expression of genuine, or would-be Roman Catholic faith. (Mahler had converted in 1897, almost certainly for political reasons.) There is no mention of God the Father in the final scene of Faust, and although Christ is referenced, he doesn’t even get a name-check.

There is also the question of Mary, Queen of Heaven in the eighth, the eternal goddess who, as Mahler made clear at the time, represents the female creative principle at work in the male mind, a force contained within the divine figure of Eros, that is hymned so ecstatically in the symphony’s closing pages. Mahler was no ‘musician’s musician’: he was a Viennese contemporary of Gustav Klimt and Sigmund Freud and eventually consulted the psychiatrist when the dangerous intensity of his obsession with Alma became all too clear.

But Mary is also something else. The fact that those in the higher circles of heaven appear to be female was iconoclastic at the time and it is clear that she is also Alma. Thus the Eighth took on a more urgent personal significance – it must now be the instrument to win Alma back. Did he succeed, if only momentarily, or only in part? The answer to that appears to be a tantalizing yes and no.

So how should we see the Eighth Symphony now? Blowing away long-held misconceptions is important, of course, but a reconnection with Mahler’s world-embracing, inclusive vision is vital. In this age of strident identity politics, where people divide into groups and fling accusations and abuse across the e-barricades, Mahler’s Goethean notion of ‘world-citizenship’, in which each embraces the other, and we all face the contradictions within ourselves, is a message well worth reaffirming.



The Telegraph 
Was Mahler killed by his own symphony?

2 March 2020
His ‘Eighth’ offers an inclusive, idealistic world vision, but it may have taken a fatal toll on the composer. In 1910, right at the end of his life, Gustav Mahler finally made his breakthrough as a composer. Until then, music-lovers across the western world saw him as a great conductor who also composed.
Read the full article

BBC Proms Guide 
Vaughan Williams - Two-Way Vision

Anniversaries are rarely better timed than this one. No twentieth century British composer stands more in need of reassessment than Ralph Vaughan Williams. You might wonder why a composer whose position at the top of the Classic FM ‘Hall of Fame’ list is beginning to look like a permanent fixture should be a candidate for urgent revaluation. It’s not as though the work that regularly emerges as the nation’s favourite, The Lark Ascending, is anything less than top-drawer VW.
Read the full article

The Guardian
Per Nørgård - Night Vision

13 July 2004

Per Nørgård is unique. No-one who knows the 68 year-old Danish composer and his bizarrely wonderful music is likely to disagree with that. There are people who, as Thomas Hardy put it, carry their own atmosphere around them like a planet. Nørgård is one of them. To spend three-quarters with an hour with him (as I did early in April) is to be transported from the mundane reality of a fashionable London cafe to a world where normal laws hardly seem relevant.
Read the full article

BBC Music Magazine
What Happened When the Wall Came Down?

September 2002

There’s a telling little scene in George Schultz's famous Peanuts cartoon strip. Linus and his sister Lucy are sitting together, reading. Linus looks up from his book and says: ‘Did you know that in the old days people thought the world was flat, and if you sailed too far you’d fall off the edge and be eaten by monsters?’ Both children laugh helplessly. Then Lucy frowns, and asks: ‘What do we think now?’
Read the full article


Opera Explained Wagner: The Ring of the Nibelung

Opera Explained
Wagner: The Ring of the Nibelung

Naxos  8.558184-85 (2 CDs)
Released October 2007

Wagner’s Ring cycle is the most ambitious work in the history of music: four operas that combine to tell a single epic story. Based in legend, it has become a legend in its own right: a supreme challenge for conductors, singers, opera producers, and indeed for audiences.

But for all its grandeur and complexity, The Ringis far more accessible than many music lovers think. In this two-CD guide Stephen Johnson explains the basics of the plot, profiles the leading characters, and shows how Wagner’s revolutionary music adds fascinating layers of meaning and psychological insight, as well as providing some of the most stirring and intoxicating moments in the entire operatic repertoire.

Buy online from
Buy from Classic Online